The premiere of Yellowstone Season 5 Part 2, titled “Desire Is All You Need,” brings fans the heart-wrenching moment they both dreaded and anticipated: the death of John Dutton. The episode’s focus shifts between the immediate fallout of John’s death and scenes from six weeks prior, diffusing the impact of his passing and leaving viewers wanting a more direct exploration of the family’s grief and turmoil.
Though John’s murder, staged as a suicide by the cunning Sarah Atwood, is at the core of the episode, interlaced scenes of Rip’s crew adjusting to life on the 6666 Ranch feel misplaced. While these cowboy vignettes showcase Sheridan’s love for ranch life, they detract from the intense emotional weight of John’s tragic end. Sarah’s choice to frame John’s death as a suicide, though bold, feels inconsistent for her character and raises immediate suspicion from the Duttons, especially Beth, whose grief quickly turns to fury aimed at Jamie.
Beth’s raw emotion provides the most compelling moments as she grapples with betrayal and loss, setting the stage for a revenge-fueled arc against Jamie. Meanwhile, Jamie’s continued insecurity and manipulation reveal a man driven by desperation rather than control.
Ultimately, the premiere is a mix of poignant emotion and diluted storytelling. While the family’s reactions to John’s death are powerful, split narratives and less effective plot choices lessen the intended impact. With more focus, the season may deliver the catharsis and closure fans expect from Costner’s departure and John Dutton’s legacy.
